MonsterInsights vs Site Kit: Google's Plugin or Paid Toggles

The short answer: if you want GA4, Search Console and PageSpeed Insights in one WordPress dashboard, and your forms and shop run on plugins Site Kit already tracks, Site Kit by Google does the job for nothing, and its wordpress.org listing says the plugin is free and open source and will remain so. MonsterInsights earns its fee when you need the store itself reported inside WordPress, with revenue, a purchase funnel, coupons and abandoned carts: that is Pro, $199.50 for the first year and $399.00 a year after (checked on 26 October 2026 on the MonsterInsights pricing page). Below that need, Google's own plugin is the default worth beating.

Disclosure: I may earn a commission through some links on this site. It does not change what this page says.

Red flags before you install either:

1. A second Google tag. MonsterInsights' FAQ says another Google Analytics plugin interferes with tracking and skews the data, so this is one plugin or the other for Analytics, never both. For example, if you try MonsterInsights Plus and keep it, two years cost $99.50 + $199.00 = $298.50, per the pricing page; try Site Kit first and that figure is the price of whatever it could not do.
2. Your form and shop plugins. Site Kit's plugin conversion tracking supports eight: Contact Form 7, MailChimp, OptinMonster, Popup Maker, WPForms, WooCommerce, Ninja Forms and Easy Digital Downloads. If yours is on that list, Site Kit sends its events to GA4 and Google Ads; if it is not, MonsterInsights' wider list on wordpress.org is the place to look.
3. A multisite network. Site Kit's known limitations say it does not support WordPress multisite networks and has to be activated site by site. MonsterInsights Elite lists multisite support on its pricing card.

Feature by feature

Sources, read on 26 October 2026: Site Kit's wordpress.org listing, consent mode, plugin conversion tracking, email reports and known limitations; MonsterInsights' pricing, wordpress.org listing and EU Compliance guide.

Where the choice turns

What free covers

Site Kit covers many Google products at a summary level. It places the Google tag, Tag Manager or the AdSense snippet without code, shows metrics for the whole site and for individual posts, and emails weekly, monthly or quarterly reports to dashboard users who opt in. The wordpress.org FAQ adds the fine print: the plugin is free, and the Google products inside it carry their own terms and any fees. What it does not describe is a store report inside WordPress; for revenue by product you open GA4.

Consent, set up two ways

Site Kit's consent mode page is unusually specific. You switch consent mode on under Site Kit, Settings, Admin Settings; Site Kit then needs the WP Consent API plugin and a consent plugin such as Complianz, Cookiebot or CookieYes to collect the actual choice. It also states that if Analytics or Ads is connected and consent mode is left off, tracking for visitors in the European Economic Area, Switzerland and the United Kingdom is blocked. MonsterInsights takes the plugin route instead: its EU Compliance addon, from Plus, holds tracking until one of four named consent plugins reports a yes. Either way the duty is yours: Google's consent mode overview says the site owner is responsible for obtaining consent, which for analytics cookies comes from Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive. The full set-up and the questions for counsel are in consent-friendly EU analytics.

The store

On a WooCommerce site, Site Kit's conversion tracking sends shop events to GA4, and the reading happens in GA4. MonsterInsights Pro reads them back into WordPress as a store report, a funnel from product view to purchase, and coupon and cart abandonment reports, per its wordpress.org listing. That is the clearest thing the licence buys.

One check an agent can run after a switch

Both plugins write to the same kind of GA4 property, so Google's read-only Analytics MCP server works the same behind either. If you move from one plugin to the other, ask the agent for daily users by country for the seven days before and after the switch. A person reads the result for a step down in EEA countries, which points to a change in how consent is handled, then opens the page source and looks for the line "Google tag (gtag.js) Consent Mode snippet added by Site Kit" that the consent mode page tells you to search for. The agent finds the change; a person decides whether it is a fault.

Choose Site Kit if

• You want Search Console, GA4, PageSpeed and AdSense set up in one free plugin.
• Your forms and shop run on the eight plugins its conversion tracking supports.
• You will read detailed reports in GA4 itself and want a summary in WordPress.

Choose MonsterInsights if

• A shop needs revenue, funnel, coupon and cart abandonment reports inside WordPress.
• Your form or membership plugin is outside Site Kit's list and on MonsterInsights' integrations.
• You run a multisite network, which Elite supports and Site Kit does not.

Start with the free plugin

Install Site Kit first, connect Analytics and Search Console, switch on consent mode if you have EU visitors, and live with it for a month. Write down every question it cannot answer in WordPress. If the list is empty, or every item is answered in GA4 by someone who already opens it, you are done at no cost.

If the list names store reports, read the vendor's own comparison with care. MonsterInsights' answer to "Why choose Google Analytics by MonsterInsights vs Google Site Kit?" on its wordpress.org listing still names Google Optimize support among its advantages, and Google's help centre says Optimize was no longer available as of 30 September 2023. The answer is written by the side that sells the licence, so weigh it as a sales page and check each item it lists against the feature table above.

FAQ

Can I use Site Kit and MonsterInsights together?

Not for Analytics. MonsterInsights' FAQ says to uninstall other Google Analytics plugins first, because running two interferes with tracking and skews the data.

Is Site Kit GDPR compliant?

Its wordpress.org FAQ says site owners are responsible for notice and consent requirements, and that Site Kit anonymises IP addresses by default when the Analytics module is activated, a setting you can switch off.

Does Site Kit work on WordPress multisite?

Not as a network. Its known limitations page says to activate the plugin on each individual site you want to use it on.