Lemon Squeezy vs Paddle: One Headline Fee, Different Extras

The short answer: for a $50-a-month SaaS plan sold mostly to customers outside the US, Lemon Squeezy's surcharges lift the fee on each renewal to $4.00, while Paddle's pricing page lists the same 5% + 50¢ with no added costs, $3.00; at 400 subscribers that gap is $400 a month (checked on 26 October 2026 on the Lemon Squeezy fees page and the Paddle pricing page). For a one-off product sold to US buyers by card, the two charge the same. Choose Lemon Squeezy if your job is a small software or digital-product business with mostly US buyers that wants a store, licence keys and email marketing in one place, and you accept that its owner, Stripe, is steering users toward Stripe Managed Payments. Choose Paddle if your job is a subscription business selling across many countries that wants payouts in its own currency and billing support handled for its customers.

Disclosure: I may earn a commission through some links on this site. It does not change what this page says.

Price your own mix before the logos:

1. One renewal, itemised. For example, a $50 monthly renewal from a buyer outside the US on Lemon Squeezy is $0.50 + 5% ($2.50) + 1.5% international ($0.75) + 0.5% subscription ($0.25) = $4.00, or 8% of the price. On Paddle it is $0.50 + 5% = $3.00, per its pricing page. Before tax; Lemon Squeezy's fees page takes its percentage from the total including tax.
2. The split your current processor already shows. Pull last quarter's payments by buyer country, by payment method and by one-off against recurring from the dashboard you use today. Lemon Squeezy's extras apply to non-US buyers, PayPal and subscriptions; if your sales are one-off card payments from the US, the fees page adds nothing and the comparison ends level.
3. The rate that tells you it worked. Each month, gross sales minus what reached your bank, divided by gross sales, with payout and conversion costs included. Compare it with the last three months on your current platform before you call a switch cheaper.

Fee and payout lines, side by side

Read on 26 October 2026 on the Lemon Squeezy fees page and getting paid guide, the Paddle pricing page and FAQ, and Paddle's help articles on payout timing and payout fees.

Where the two merchants of record differ

What each takes on, and what it leaves you

Lemon Squeezy's merchant of record page lists sales tax, refunds, chargebacks and PCI compliance, and its sales tax page says the tax on your payouts, as income, may still be yours. Paddle says it is registered in over 100 jurisdictions, calculates, charges and remits the tax and issues the invoices, with the tax risk resting with Paddle, per its VAT article. One detail for your accountant: your own sale to Paddle is a cross-border business sale under reverse charge, so you charge Paddle no VAT, per its payout VAT article.

Who your customer deals with

Paddle's pricing includes billing support for your customers' payment, subscription and cancellation questions, and its developer overview says your name appears on the customer's statement alongside Paddle's. Lemon Squeezy's pricing FAQ gives a support response time of 24 to 48 hours for sellers, and its CEO's 2026 update acknowledged slower support responses while the team worked on Stripe's product. For a SaaS company whose renewals generate tickets, that is the difference that shows up in the inbox.

What each owner is building

Lemon Squeezy's CEO wrote on 28 January 2026 that the team is building Stripe Managed Payments and that the goal is an easy way for Lemon Squeezy users to migrate to it (2026 update). Paddle's AI toolkit page puts its effort into agent tooling: a docs MCP server, a billing MCP server and skills for coding agents. Read both as statements of direction, not as dates.

A catalogue rebuilt in Paddle's sandbox by agent

Paddle documents a hosted MCP server with separate sandbox and live addresses. Its docs warn that the server does not gate destructive operations and recommend approving each action in your client.

1. Create a sandbox API key with only product and price permissions, connect it to https://sandbox-mcp.paddle.com/mcp, and switch your client to ask permission before every execute.
2. Paste in your Lemon Squeezy products and variants with their prices, and ask the agent to create the same products and prices in the sandbox, with a euro price for each plan, showing every call before it runs.
3. The human check: someone opens the sandbox catalogue in Paddle's dashboard, compares every price and billing interval with the Lemon Squeezy store, and runs a sandbox checkout. Only after that does anyone connect the live server, which starts with read access under OAuth.

Free tests, and the payout default

Both cost nothing until you sell: Lemon Squeezy builds a store in test mode without a card, per its pricing page, and Paddle offers a developer sandbox, per the MCP docs. Build one plan in each and run the checkout as a customer in another country.

Then look at the payout settings you are about to accept. Lemon Squeezy's getting paid guide makes bank payouts in USD and converts them, and its fees page takes 1% of every payout to a bank outside the US: a seller with a euro account gives up $10 of each $1,000 paid out, a charge Paddle's same-currency SEPA transfer does not make. That 1% is a fee on getting your own money home, and it repeats twice a month.

Lemon Squeezy suits you when

• Most buyers are in the US and pay by card, where its fee matches Paddle's.
• You want a hosted store, email marketing free up to 500 subscribers and licence keys in one account (pricing page).
• You keep exports current and will review Stripe Managed Payments when the migration path opens.

Paddle suits you when

• Renewals from outside the US are most of your revenue.
• You want payouts in euros or pounds without a conversion on every transfer.
• Customer billing questions should go to the platform, not to your support inbox.

The Lemon Squeezy entry lists its surcharges, and how to use Lemon Squeezy sets up a SaaS plan with a free trial and webhooks.

FAQ

Do Paddle and Lemon Squeezy charge the same fee?

The headline is the same 5% + 50¢. Lemon Squeezy adds 1.5% for buyers outside the US, 1.5% for PayPal and 0.5% for subscription payments; Paddle's pricing page lists no added costs (Lemon Squeezy fees, Paddle pricing).

Can I move from Paddle to Lemon Squeezy, or back?

Lemon Squeezy documents a Paddle migration covering products, customers, payment methods, subscriptions, coupons and licence keys. Paddle's pricing FAQ says there is no lock-in and your data can be migrated to another provider.

When does Paddle pay out?

Once a month: a balance above your threshold, $100 at least, becomes a payout on the 1st and is sent by the 15th (payout article).