REVIEWS.io vs Judge.me: A Flat $15 or Reviews Beyond Shopify

The short answer: on Shopify, Judge.me is hard to argue with on price: its Awesome plan costs $15 a month whatever your order volume, includes Google Shopping product ratings once you have 50 eligible reviews, and the Free plan below it already sends unlimited review requests (Judge.me pricing, Google Shopping article). Off Shopify the choice is made for you: Judge.me has shut down on every other platform (sunsetting article), and REVIEWS.io still runs on WooCommerce, BigCommerce and Magento, with Google stars from Start-Up at $79 a month for up to 1,000 invitations (REVIEWS.io pricing). All checked on 26 October 2026.

Disclosure: I may earn a commission through some links on this site. It does not change what this page says.

What to settle first:

1. What the gap costs over a year. For example, a Shopify store with 5,000 orders a month pays REVIEWS.io's Start-Up rate for 5,000 invitations, $130 a month, so 12 x $130 = $1,560 a year, against 12 x $15 = $180 on Judge.me Awesome, per the REVIEWS.io and Judge.me pricing pages. The $1,380 difference has to buy something you will use.
2. The platform under the store. REVIEWS.io's invitation triggers are documented for Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Magento, Shopware and Squarespace (How Review Invitations Work). Judge.me now serves Shopify only. If a replatform is on next year's list, that settles more than any feature.
3. The count Google needs. Both put product stars in Google Shopping from 50 reviews: eligible reviews on Judge.me, and on REVIEWS.io 50 product reviews with at least 3 on one product (REVIEWS.io Google article). Check your count each month; it is the milestone that pays.

How they line up

From the REVIEWS.io pricing page, its Google and auto-publishing articles and homepage FAQ, and Judge.me's pricing page and publishing article.

Where they part ways

One platform or many

Judge.me's help centre says it has sunset the app on WooCommerce, Square, Squarespace, BigCommerce, Duda and PrestaShop to put its resources into Shopify (sunsetting article). On Shopify that focus shows: Shop app sync, a Sidekick integration, Shopify Flow. Everywhere else it is no longer an option, and REVIEWS.io is the one of these two still serving those stores.

A price that moves and one that does not

REVIEWS.io prices by invitations: at up to 1,000 orders a month Start-Up is $79 and Grow $175, at 2,500 they are $100 and $225, at 5,000 they are $130 and $275 (pricing). What the extra money buys is company reviews for Google Seller Ratings, surveys, a reputation manager on Grow, month-to-month billing and support for more than one platform. Judge.me's two plans never move, and its pricing page says $15 a month is the most a store will ever pay it (Judge.me pricing).

What happens to a two-star review

Out of the box, REVIEWS.io publishes each verified review as it arrives and Judge.me publishes every new review. Both let you raise the bar, REVIEWS.io with a minimum star rating and Judge.me with rating or sentiment rules on Awesome, and both then publish anything held back after 14 days (REVIEWS.io, Judge.me). Judge.me also has a switch that hides every new review until someone publishes it by hand, and hidden reviews stay hidden. That switch is where the law comes in: recital 49 of the EU's Omnibus Directive says traders should be prohibited from manipulating consumer reviews, such as publishing only positive reviews and deleting the negative ones. The rules in full, with what they mean for a review widget, are in How to use REVIEWS.io.

One AI step: Sidekick finds the review, a person sends the reply

With Judge.me installed, Shopify's Sidekick reads your Judge.me data with no setup, on the Free plan too (Sidekick article). Ask it: "Show me this month's one- and two-star reviews that mention delivery." Then: "Reply to this review." Sidekick does not post anything itself; for actions it opens Judge.me in a pop-up to confirm or cancel, and for replies it opens the reply window with a draft you can edit, or regenerate with AI on Awesome.

The person replying checks the order before the words: was the parcel late, what does the customer get now, does the reply promise only what the shop will do. Then edit and send. A private reply goes by email and cannot be unsent, per Judge.me's replying article, so public is the safer default for a first draft.

The free route first

On Shopify, install Judge.me Free and collect for two months; unlimited requests cost nothing, and the 50-review count for Google Shopping is the point where Awesome at $15 starts to earn its keep (Judge.me pricing). On another platform, use REVIEWS.io's 14-day trial to connect the store and check product identifiers, knowing the trial is capped at 25 invitations (How Review Invitations Work).

Watch the setting that sets your price. REVIEWS.io's default Flow queues an invitation for every order that reaches the trigger status, Fulfilled on Shopify, and its plans are priced in invitations a month (How Review Invitations Work), so the automation you leave switched on is the one that walks the account up the tiers as orders grow; at Judge.me the same growth leaves the bill at $15.

Choose REVIEWS.io if your job is

• Collecting reviews on WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Magento or Shopware.
• Getting seller stars into Google Ads from company reviews, alongside product stars.
• Keeping reviews and surveys in one tool you can leave month to month, with an export.

Choose Judge.me if your job is

• Collecting product reviews on a Shopify store for a fixed, small monthly cost.
• Getting product stars into Google Shopping without a tier that grows with orders.
• Managing reviews from Shopify's admin, through Sidekick and Shopify Flow.

FAQ

Can I move my Judge.me reviews to REVIEWS.io later?

Yes, with conditions: imports need Start-Up or above, must be requested within the first 90 days of the REVIEWS.io account, and are limited to one import per review type (import requirements). Imported reviews do not carry the Verified Buyer badge, and imported company reviews do not count toward Google Seller Ratings (3rd party vs verified).

Does Judge.me still work on WooCommerce?

No. Its help centre says Judge.me has been sunset on all non-Shopify platforms, WooCommerce included (sunsetting article).

Which one puts stars in Google Shopping sooner?

Neither, on volume alone: both need 50 qualifying product reviews. What differs is the plan: Awesome at $15 on Judge.me, Start-Up at $79 or more on REVIEWS.io, and on REVIEWS.io the product identifiers must match your Merchant Center feed (Google article).